Secondary analysis of an RCT in 886 smokers: abstainers in the e-cigarette arm relapsed less than those in the NRT arm (RR 0.78 from 4 weeks to 1 year). Abstainers who used e-cigarettes also relapsed less than non-users (RR 0.79), an association.
Secondary analysisn = 886
Hajek et al. Continuing use of e-cigarettes after stopping smoking and relapse: Secondary analysis of a large randomised controlled trial